Comedy duo Laurel and Hardy posing behind a modern man in glasses. The two comedians, wearing bowler hats and dark suits, hold a finger to their lips in a playful "shh" gesture, while the man in the center looks forward with a gentle smile.

The Devil’s Brother: Laurel and Hardy Get the Operatic Treatment

Comedy duo Laurel and Hardy posing behind a modern man in glasses. The two comedians, wearing bowler hats and dark suits, hold a finger to their lips in a playful "shh" gesture, while the man in the center looks forward with a gentle smile.

I was never much of a fan of musicals from this period, and I can imagine Hal Roach watching Hollywood’s latest craze with the cold calculation of a man spotting a cash register with legs. Musicals were selling, so why not dress up his biggest stars Laurel and Hardy in fancy period costumes, throw in a few opera singers and see what the public would swallow? It didn’t matter if Laurel and Hardy looked like two delivery men who had wandered onto the wrong movie set. Roach saw a trend, smelled a box-office opportunity and sent his boys marching into it.

My advice? Get ready to fast-forward through some of the musical numbers and keep your eyes open for the real treasures: those rare moments when Stan and Ollie are allowed to do what they do best. There is some wonderful comedy hiding in this operatic production, and it is worth the search.

I sometimes wonder what Roach would have done if Laurel and Hardy were still around in the 1970s. Would he have shoved them into a gritty cop movie because police dramas were suddenly popular? Maybe a buddy picture or a disaster movie. I can see Stan and Ollie chasing bank robbers in bell-bottoms while Roach counts the receipts and calls it a bold new direction. Some things are best left to the imagination.

An operatic gamble

Released on May 5, 1933, The Devil’s Brother was also known as Fra Diavolo, the title used for its preview and working title. The story comes from Daniel Auber’s 1830 French opera, with a libretto by Eugène Scribe. In the film, Dennis King plays the charming bandit Fra Diavolo, while Stan and Ollie become Stanlio and Ollio, two unlucky fellows who decide that a life of banditry might help them recover their stolen savings. Naturally, their plans go sideways.

Roach shared the directing credit with Charles Rogers. The division of labour is especially interesting: accounts of the production describe Rogers handling the comedy sequences while Roach took charge of the straight dramatic material and musical numbers. That helps explain the film’s split personality. One minute we are in an operetta, the next Stan and Ollie are doing what they do best, turning a simple situation into a small disaster.

Fast-forward the singing, stay for the laughs

Thelma Todd plays Lady Pamela, James Finlayson is Lord Rocberg, and the cast gives the film a proper dose of Hollywood character. But the main attraction for Laurel and Hardy fans is the comedy tucked between the musical passages. Watch for Stan’s increasingly frantic “Kneesy-Earsy-Nosey” routine, the “Finger Wiggle,” the wine-cellar sequence and the classic line, “Come easy, go easy. That’s my motto.” The finale, involving a bull and a very unfortunate handkerchief, brings the chaos home.

Stan Laurel later looked back on the film with unusual affection. In an August 1957 interview, he reportedly said, “Our best was Fra Diavolo. We both agreed on that.” It’s a revealing endorsement from a performer who knew exactly what worked for the team. Even if the musical sections are not your cup of tea, there is clearly something about this picture that stayed with him.

A new look at an old Hollywood curiosity

Warner Archive’s new Blu-ray arrives November 24, 2026, with a new HD master sourced from a 4K scan of the best preservation elements. The release includes an audio commentary by Leonard Maltin and Richard W. Bann, the MGM short Hello, Pop, Laurel and Hardy excerpts from The Hollywood Revue of 1929, The Rogue Song and Pick a Star, plus the original theatrical trailer.

The Devil’s Brother may not be the Laurel and Hardy feature I would reach for first, especially if I am in the mood for wall-to-wall comedy rather than opera. But skip past the songs and there are some lovely comic moments waiting. Roach may have been chasing the latest Hollywood craze, but at least he brought his two best troublemakers along for the ride. And when Stan and Ollie finally get loose, the musical can wait.


Discover more from Sandbox World

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.