Dark blue high-top sneakers with tan trousers, one front shoelace undone and trailing across a tiled floor.

Why Do My Shoelaces Keep Coming Undone? The Science of a Knotty Problem

Dark blue high-top sneakers with tan trousers, one front shoelace undone and trailing across a tiled floor.

I have one pair of shoes with a shoelace that refuses to stay tied. I pull it tight, double-knot it and head out. Before long, it’s dangling again. One of these days, I’m going to faceplant on the pavement and need my teeth surgically reconstructed.

Then I came across astrophysicist Josie Peters explaining why shoelaces come undone. My first thought was, what the hell does an astrophysicist know about shoelaces? Isn’t there a galaxy somewhere that needs investigating?

As it turns out, quite a lot. Shoelace knots offer a surprisingly clever way to explain physics, topology and even theories about cosmic strings. I was trying to keep my shoes on my feet. I wasn’t expecting an astronomy lesson.

Peters explains that the problem comes down to movement and force. Every step puts our shoelace knots to work. The impact of our feet hitting the ground loosens the knot, while the swinging motion of our legs makes the loose ends whip back and forth. Eventually, the knot gives up.

Researchers at the University of California, Berkeley, studied the problem in 2017, filming a runner on a treadmill in slow motion. Their findings showed how these two forces work together to unravel a knot. In other words, your daily walk is working against your shoelaces.

The type of knot matters, too. A reef knot is generally more secure, while a granny knot is more likely to twist and come undone. The difference is in the direction you cross the loops. A small change in how you tie your shoes can make a big difference.

And there are more ways to tie your shoes than most of us could imagine. Ian Fieggen, better known as Professor Shoelace, documents 25 different knots on Ian’s Shoelace Site. His collection includes the standard knot, the surgeon’s knot, the Berluti knot and the speedy Ian Knot.

The possibilities don’t end with knots. Fieggen calculates that a standard shoe with six pairs of eyelets can be laced in almost two trillion mathematical combinations. That’s a lot of choices for something most of us learned to do in kindergarten.

Watch: Why Do My Shoelaces Keep Coming Undone?

Astrophysicist Josie Peters explores the science behind those troublesome knots in this BBC Ideas video.

Video credit: BBC Ideas

For more knot discoveries, visit Ian’s Shoelace Site, featuring an impressive collection of knots and lacing techniques.

No matter how tightly I double-knotted the laces, my shoe seemed to have a mind of its own, stubbornly refusing to stay tied.


Discover more from Sandbox World

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.